8 years of womensweb

It’s Complicated: Helping Children Deal With Winning & Losing

Posted: October 6, 2012

We had been following the celebrity dance show “Jhalak Dikh La Ja” this season. Our 6 year old daughter is allowed to watch some of the programs on Television with us, provided they meet our parental guidance standard. This dance show was obviously very much of a suitable watch and she would eagerly await next week, every week! Towards the end of the show, she had even started speculating and predicting on who the winner would be.

“I know who will win,” she said after the last vote appeal was made by the contestants. “It’s going to be Raashmi-Desai-Sandhu because she performed the best and earned the highest marks from the judges.” Earlier, I had taken great pains to explain to her how the marks awarded by judges were directly related to the performance and the contestant who performed well moved forward in the show with the support of the audience and the best one ultimately won.

Who is a winner?After Gurmeet Choudhary won, my daughter was bitterly disappointed. It was as if her whole foundation of belief had shaken up. “How could this happen?” she asked. “Raashmi scored the most, she performed the best, and judges gave her the highest marks!” So then I said it was also on the number of votes a celebrity receives. So her next question was “then why wouldn’t people want to vote for the best?” And wouldn’t Raashmi cry and feel angry that although she was the best, she lost? “ “I guess she would” was all I had to say to that question.  But it did get me thinking. How does one explain to a child that doing your best may not guarantee the desired results, not always.

If she was an adult I would have told her the best person does not always win and your hard work is not always paid off and one should take failure in stride and move on in life. Success is never ending and failure is never final, as the popular book title goes.    Defeat in a competition should not make us bitter, if anything it should make us thankful for that kind of an opportunity and help us and work on our limitations. Sure, there is bound to be disappointment but you cannot let it bog you down. Life isn’t always fair.  You may lose even if you deserved to win and did everything you could to succeed. Luck plays an important role in our achievements but working hard makes your case stronger and raises your chances. There is something to be learnt from every failure and if you are not a good loser, you probably won’t make a humble winner either.

But since my daughter is  just 6 years old, I found it difficult to explain myself on the contradictory stand taken. On one hand I told her you must work hard and perform better than others to win and at the conclusion of the show I declared that people may choose to vote for their favorite celebrity, irrespective of their performance rating!

We had quite a bit of a discussion that night and I am still looking for the perfect answer to her question. Something conveying that being the best does not guarantee a win and at the same time coming second is not always an indication of your talents. Words of wisdom that would retain her optimistic attitude and yet prepare her for rejection in life. Yeah, it is kind of complicated.

Pic credit: Robert Linder 

An avid reader and a hobbyist writer, my sanity and survival depend entirely on the

Learn More

VIDEO OF THE WEEK

Comments

5 Comments


  1. Oh my god! What a blog.. what a blog.. it’s so true. I am so glad that some parent, took an initiative to reckon that preparing kids for rejection in life is important. Most of the parents prepare their kids for success. But as you said, life is unfair and therefore, preparing them for it is as much as important!

    Hats off for at least reckoning the problem. Someday the solution will follow 🙂

  2. First of all, thoughtful idea and topic. I have moved to Austin, TX and have been reading most of your posts through a friend.

    I would however share my disagreements on some of the basic concepts here.
    1. In my view, reality show (read: Manipulated Reality Shows) are not the best barometer for kids to make them learn about attempts, success, failure etc etc
    2. There is always one more thing to learn, if final objective is self-improvement
    3. Votes, Medal etc are socially accepted way to rank people, but not the only way or not the right way on many instances. Talent, practice, expertise and efficiency are some of the values which always gets respect and one does not need to “sale” them in most instances

    Having said this, 6 year is not the age to see dramatic reality shows, or to talk more of results, how it works etc etc stuff. What they should know and learn is “Have fun and do not worry about results”..

    Many a times it is the parent who wants their child to be something, at some rank, winner.. whatever to make their social status newsworthy

    I do not claim, that was the case in this story. I am just sharing a different thought process. Feel free to disagree.

    • Oh yes, I totally agree, reality shows are for entertainment and in no way a barometer to teach anything to kids..BUT…kids being kids have questions for and on everything and sometimes you ‘ve got to come up with an answer though not necessarily to the point and absolutely true..I would say something between the two since it is actually on a show! The aim is of course to have fun and not worry about results but that’s easier said than done because when you watch the whole series you do feel involved in some way.The only point I disagree on is a 6 year old watching such shows, i think it is one of the few decent shows on air (and less dramatic as compared to others).and its something we loved watching together as a family!!( I do not enjoy watching strawberry shortcake!)
      Appreciate your comment and some very good points made in it. Thanks

  3. hi gauri madam husein here how r u doing madam

Share your thoughts! [Be civil. No personal attacks. Longer comment policy in our footer!]

Feminist Book Picks

Stay updated with our Weekly Newsletter or Daily Summary - or both!

Learn to make Content work for you!