Whose Fault Is It Anyway?

Posted: April 24, 2012
Tags:

I often read in newspapers and see on TV with nauseating regularity that some helpless woman somewhere in the country has been killed for dowry. Some die within weeks of marriage, some within months or years, but the underlying story is the same- the greed of the in-laws. It is a never-ending cycle of marriage-dowry-death, and yet we learn no lessons.

[Statistically speaking, the National Crime Records Bureau’s report for 2010 says that 8391 cases of dowry deaths were reported in the country in 2010 (that is about 23 dowry deaths a day, with Delhi alone accounting for 14.6% of dowry deaths reported from 35 major cities), while 94041 cases of cruelty by husband and/or relatives were reported for the same year (that is about 258 cases per day)]

A very sad aspect of this issue is that many a times the woman does let her parents know about the beatings, the taunts and the demands, but what do her parents do? Tell her to ‘adjust’ because now she belongs to the husband and her family; give in to the dowry demands till they can; or just ignore the pleadings of their own daughter, and brush the cruelty under the carpet till it is too late. After all, the izzat of the family is paramount. What will people say? How will we face the world?

To me the dowry giver is as much to blame as the dowry seeker. I know many people will tell me that I don’t understand, that dowry is part of the Indian system, that marriages can’t take place without giving ‘something’, that what they give is for their daughter’s happiness, etc. etc. ad nauseum. This is utter nonsense and an admission that we, as parents of daughters are weaklings, and once we have washed our hands off our daughters, we can put our blinkers on and go on with our placid lives where our daughters do not remain ours, for haven’t we done their daankanya daan it is called, isn’t it? My Hindi is not so good, but to me daan means donation or gift, as in giving away. We don’t just give away our daughters; we give away our self respect and our responsibility towards our daughters and leave them to die. They die less because of dowry and more because we cease to be parents; because we hand them over to others lock, stock and barrel, more particularly in these cases we give away our daughters’ lives, limbs and liberty.

And then we weep, we blame the system, we scream for stringent punishment for the in-laws and the husband, we curse the police and the courts, yet even now we do not have the guts to own up to our own responsibility- that we were willingly part of a system that is unfair, unjust, inhuman and plain pathetic, and we pushed our daughters into it, because after all, dowry is part of our culture.

Now did I say culture? What kind of culture is this? Can we, at least some of us, stand up and say no? But again, saying no won’t be so easy, because we have not brought up our daughters to be self-reliant, thinking human beings. We have brought them up to be educated enough to marry into decent (?) families, produce children- I mean sons, cook, clean and be nursemaids to the whole household of the husband. After all, a daughter is paraya dhan– someone else’s property, for that someone to decide whether she lives or dies.

About the fate of our daughters- how we bring them up, and what we do with their lives, I can’t put it better than Vrinda Nabar, who, in her fantastic book ‘Caste as Woman’ (Penguin India, 1995), says, and I quote:

Bring out the silver & polish the brass
Brush off the cobwebs, and clean all the glass
Unlock the pantry, lay out the food
Keep away grandma, her manners are crude.

We’ve got a daughter we are willing to sell
He is the bargain, the profit as well
He’s coming to see for himself, so he said
How she and our money would look in his bed

Our daughter’s a graduate, he’s no cause to moan
She’s a well brought up girl with no mind of her own
She speaks English well, has a fair pretty face
And is five foot four inches by Lord Bhagwan’s grace

Of course she’ll be happy, I’ll tell you that flat
She’ll have her own home, produce brat after brat
Forget all her youth, as she spins out her life
In waddling behind him, a good Indian wife.

And she’ll long to have sons; they’re boons from above
Take it from me that they’re proof of God’s love
And when all her daughters are suitably grown
She’ll marry them off as we’ve done our own.

Finally, this is what I read about the meaning of kanya daan on the WWW:

“The ritual of Kanya Daan is considered very auspicious in Hindu religion. It is a very pious and dutiful ritual which is said to bring fortune as well as relief from the sins for the bride’s parents… Kanya Daan means when the father hands over all his rights and duties towards his daughter to her prospective groom. This way the father gives her daughter as a gift to the groom. As per tradition, groom is considered a form of Lord Vishnu. Thus, presenting him gifts is deemed as the greatest honor for the parents of the bride. As a result, they offer their daughter to the groom, who is their most cherished gift. As a symbol of acceptance, the groom touches the right shoulder of the bride, promising to take care of her and holding her responsibility…”

Am I correct in assuming that giving away my daughter to an “incarnation of Lord Vishnu” (how sick can one get?) will give me a fortune and wash away my sins?

*Photo credit: madaboutasia (Used under the Creative Commons Attribution License)

I am a former bureaucrat, and have worked a lot on gender issues, disaster management

Learn More

VIDEO OF THE WEEK

Comments

13 Comments


  1. I am always in awe when I read you. God bless you and your daughters.!

  2. Sir, as always your post strikes a chord!
    The fear of going against what the society expects from you, will take at least another generation to kill. This is bound to change with the current generation which is not scared to go against what it deems incorrect in the society.

  3. The dowry that was given to girls was earlier called ‘Streedhan’ and was given to her as her share in the ancestral property. She was free to use it as she pleased. This was a sensible practice that ensured that she had something to fall back on. Those were days when she was not encouraged to study or take up a job outside her home.

    With time ‘Strredhan’ became ‘varadakshina’ and began to be offered to the ‘demigod’ who agreed to take care of the daughter. With time the daughter became ‘paraya dhan’ entrusted to her parents for safe keep. Now the groom and his family demand a security deposit to look after the girl never mind her utility value.

    The initial purpose of giving streedhan has gone for a toss. Shame on our society for making dowry a means to flaunt one’s purchasing power.

  4. Thanks for the comments.

    Hip Grandma- most customs end up getting twisted over time and lose the original meaning.

  5. Every word written and comments made upon is not only true and the need of every moment,I think the time is of taking oath by ourselves to practice on ourselves without failing any further time.

  6. i think things are changing now a days. i am seeing more families who say that i wont give my daughter to persons who ask me dowry.
    my father didnt take, he didnt give and i am sure even i will not give or take. if everybody changes, self -realization, things would change.

  7. i think things are changing now a days. i am seeing more families who say that i wont give my daughter to persons who ask me dowry.
    my father didnt take, he didnt give and i am sure even i will not give or take. if everybody changes, self -realization, things would change.

  8. Pingback: Father Of The Bride | Women's Web: Online Community For Indian Women

  9. Pingback: Married In Haste, Loved For A Lifetime | Women's Web: Online Community For Indian Women

  10. Pingback: Cultured Much? | Women's Web: Online Community For Indian Women

  11. Pingback: Whose Fault Is It Anyway? by sunilias | Violence Against Women 2012

  12. Let me say something that many won’t admit. There are men who do not want to give dowry, but will gladly demand for themselves. That should stop too!

    Besides, the best way out, in my opinion, is to allow girls choose their own spouses. If they can choose their own profession, and their careers, aren’t they intelligent enough to choose their partners too? It is the arranged marriage that in the name of tradition, promotes dowry.

  13. Pingback: Why Khap Panchayats Are Safe In India

Share your thoughts! [Be civil. No personal attacks. Longer comment policy in our footer!]

Feminist Book Picks

Stay updated with our Weekly Newsletter or Daily Summary - or both!

An Event For Ambitious Women!