The Orange Flower is back with double energy and even stronger voices! Join us in celebrating women’s voices. Register Now
The Orange Flower is here!We are ready to hear powerful voices in sixteen different categories. Nominate for awards!
In many Indian families, the MIL-DIL relationship is full of passive or open conflict. But, does it necessarily have to be this way?
If you try and unscramble ‘Mother-in-Law’ you would be surprised by the result. The daughter-in-Law in you would wonder if it was a divine sign of acknowledgement and acceptance of what you have felt all your married life. Did you get it? No? – “Woman Hitler”, that’s what it unravels as. Did I just hear a snort and a chuckle out there..?
This is a topic close to every daughter-in-law’s heart. The excitement of marrying your beau is always interspersed with apprehension of what his mother would be like. Would she be possessive of her son or would she have a free hand? Will she have space issues or would she live and let live? Will she despise me or love me like her own? Would I meet with approval or be stamped as unworthy of her product of perfection? Will she understand today’s generation and its mindset or be deeply rooted in her own?
Check it out!
But here’s where irony steps in: you are not alone. Most of these questions and that exact feeling of nervousness? “She” feels them too. Yes, you and she are sailing in the same boat in those very turbulent waters; the difference being the perspectives both come with and the reactions both have to every situation.
Heard of Jane Austen, haven’t we? The lady who wrote that timeless piece of fiction we all fell in love with. Ever thought how uncanny the parallel is that we can draw from Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth Bennet with the relationship between the MIL and DIL? Now, you must be thinking I live in the loony bin. But no, seriously, give it a thought and you will know where I am coming from.
The two protagonists who form the baseline of this love story have two particular qualities that distance them from each other, eventually to bring them together. Those very qualities are what you will find in every MIL and DIL today – Pride & Prejudice.
In her, Pride on being the mother of the son you married and prejudice as far as whether you can fit in and meet all expectations. In you, Pride about being an independent, self made woman who knows how to manage her life and Prejudice as far as the expectations and gauging the MIL is concerned. Like it or not both have their fingers in the same pie. So what happens next? A deadlock, between the various Mr. Darcys and Elizabeth Bennets within us? Does it stay to be a relationship precariously dangling over the cliff edge all the time? Or does a time come in the journey where the two paths meet and form trails in tandem?
Most prefer the status quo and learn to live with it but whether it was the right choice is a thought that always stays at the back of the mind.
More often than not, it stays in a world of uncertainty; because, with the two Ps residing within us, the generation gap widens and makes us tread different paths not allowing them to ever intersect. Most prefer the status quo and learn to live with it but whether it was the right choice is a thought that always stays at the back of the mind. Because at the end of the day; there is a basic desire which drives these feelings –love for the same man. And one thing he would always dream of is that the two most important women in his life see eye to eye with each other, at least once in a while.
Can we give him that? Of course we can. And only we can – because between the two, if anyone holds the ability to create some magic, it is us. Why you ask? Because as clichéd as it might sound, as the younger generation there lies an ability in us to Adapt: a quality which is tough for a generation that is past its prime to easily inculcate in themselves. While the older generation might be able to see the bigger picture, they no longer have the capacity to make it happen. If we can understand this, we can move that mountain that lies between us, inch by inch.
While it is not necessary to succumb to every traditional expectation, it is possible to understand others’ point of view and resolve conflicts in a more amicable manner.
Here are my suggestions as a corollary to the universal law on a MIL –DIL equation.
1. Put yourself in ‘her’ shoes: Maybe not all the time, but once in a while. Being a generation apart, sometimes it is tough for us to understand the life our MIL has lived and the exposure she has had. If we try looking at things from her perspective we will have an idea about why she demands what she does and it will in turn help us decide the right reaction it requires without hurting her feelings, yet arriving at a reasonable solution
2. Don’t always say “No”: Agree to do those little things which might not always make sense. Sometimes those tiny expectations hardly cause a dent but because we hold a different view, they blow out of proportion. For e.g. attending certain functions or following a particular dress code for a religious occasion. If they do not shake your ground as much, do them and nip some potential disasters right at the bud. Yes, there is always an apprehension that “If I give in once, I will have to give in always.” But it need not always hold good, we can always draw a line when it becomes absolutely necessary.
3. Reason out: A time always comes when the expectations are large enough to have a massive impact on your lives. For e.g. living as a joint family or the right time to start a family. Putting your foot down and saying a vehement no might end the discussion but it will leave a lot of hurt behind as residue. Instead, reason it out and make them see your point of view; they do not always understand where we come from. Blame it on the life they led if you wish. But it will help resolve matters a lot more amicably.
4. As much as possible, communicate: Sometimes, we tend to reduce our communication, be it conversations over coffee or a chat over the latest TV soap. Make it a point to have those casual communications; they will go a long way in understanding each other and bridging the gap. So much so that with a better grasp of the person you are, a lot of expectations will die even before they are born
5. Make her aware: Sometimes today’s MILs find it hard to understand the independent, career oriented women that we are. Whether we are home makers or have a professional career, the streak of self reliance and independence is there among all. For someone coming from the older generation, this might not be all that easy to understand. It is up to us to make her more knowledgeable. That understanding, if anything will make the woman in her mighty proud of you
6. Respect her: Yes, it is a fundamental fact that we should treat others the way we want them to treat us. If you want her to respect you, first learn to respect her. Her reciprocation will follow; it might take time but it will come
7. Put your foot down, but gently: Whatever the issue at hand might be, it can be dealt with poise and gentleness. However she might react, learn to keep your cool. Remember, actions speak louder than words.
8. Learn to forgive: This goes a long way to ensuring a healthy relationship with the MIL. Yes, we get hurt; sometimes beyond measure but only if we learn to leave the baggage behind can we really move on. More than for her sake, it is for yours. Taking that stress along with us does not help in any way. Nobody is asking us to forget – it is humanly impossible but to forgive is within our reach.
These are just a few ways I can suggest of bridging the gap. This awareness that we can bring about can go a long way in building our relationship with her. Who knows it might give birth to a new one, that of friendship.
Of course, this is my experience, and my style of resolving conflicts and building bridges. What do you suggest?
Pic credit: Earth Hour (Used under a CC license)
Seeta Bodke is a Business Consultant and Senior Manager from the IT sector. After spending
Interesting and useful tips. But overall, a general ariel view of the problem. At ground level, things aren’t as easy to resolve. MILs think it is their duly or job to hate DILs and do it dilligently. DILs come with an element of fear and hence, are defensive from day one. I still cringe when I recall those deathly eyes scouring my body or that indifferent look in the eyes to my pain or tragedy of losing a parent.
Hi Anita, that experience you just narrated about the indifference to a parents loss is indeed beyond normal. Things like that are definitely not what fit into this perceptive. I do not want to generalize that MiLs hate DILs becaus frankly I don’t think that is the case…. If there are such cases, then I think it’s worth trying to go to the root of the problem and see what can be done. We have but one life and living it with hatred and despise is not how we want to spend it right? As far as the reaction to the loss goes, that’s very very sad, have you ever spoken to your husband about it? Maybe he can help make you feel better…
Sorry, got cut before I could complete…. *.. make you feel better and also speak to his mum about her attitude. If we want to lead a peaceful life, sometimes the husband has to step in.
Couldn’t agree more. When my father was on death bed..fighting for life…my then to be MIL ( our marriage was few months away) was more concerned about the marriage being postponed and all, than me or my feelings…The only regret I have is she is my soul mate’s mother…
It is way easier said than done! Everything you said can be done… but what if the MIL is adamant and bent on not liking the DIL and even doesn’t like the FIL liking or supporting the DIL… What if she cringes every time her son, the DIL’s husband, praises his wife or shares a joke and laughs with his wife?! It’s the MIL’s loss that she doesn’t like the DIL when everyone else in the world likes her!!
Hi Anita. What you describe here are your mother in laws in securities… That the two men in her life .. Her husband and her son have taken a liking for the daughter in law… Probably makes her feel that she is losing them and the rest who seem to like her as well. One thing we need to understand is that most mother in laws come from very traditional mind sets , and at their age it’s tough to change those. If there is any way on which the DIL can make her feel that she is not taking her people away it will help. I know it might seem obvious that that’s not happening but to her orthodox mind it’s a different story… Whenever I face such a problem and get irritated I ask myself one question – I fell in love with this lady’s son and there are so many things I like about him…. But where does it come from? A lot comes from the lady who gave birth to him. And if she could make him the way he is today it means there is some hope and all must not be wrong with her. The task is to find how to figure that out and ensure I live a peaceful life.. Cos at the end of the day bottling so much animosity against someone is gonna affect me and my health more than anyone else. I know this seems easier said than done,but trust me all of us go through it, it’s upto us to decide whether we just want to crib and let things be or look for a way out…hope that makes sense.
Totally agree with the animosity affecting you part.
Sorry, that remained incomplete. If we let this animosity affect us too much, then we can also get negative. I think such interference and behavior comes from deeply unhappy and insecure people.
And yes, remember to treat your own DIL differently!!!!
Aye Aye to that Ujwala 🙂
These Women Are Changing The Horrible DIL-MIL Equation For Good
Here’s Why The Belief ‘Women Are Women’s Worst Enemies!’ Is A Result Of Patriarchy
Here Is Why An Indian Daughter-in-law Is Often Labeled Uncultured And Rebellious
Don’t Be A Good Girl: A Story Of Loss And Learning
Stay updated with our Weekly Newsletter or Daily Summary - or both!
Sign in/Register & Get personalised recommendations