Good News & Bad News From Tehelka

Posted: December 15, 2013

One could not open a newspaper or turn on a news media channel for the  past week, without being constantly bombarded by the Tehelka – Tarun Tejpal case of sexual harassment. The facts of the case now stand true to the name of the publication – Tehelka, which means sensational. Perhaps no news story spawned from the Tehelka news desk has created such headlines as the antics of one of its founders, while away from it.

So, let us review the impact of what has been happening:

BAD NEWS




A head of a publication, that had positioned itself as the bastion of change has been caught on the wrong foot. Indeed, the foot that has an Achilles’ heel. The ‘sting’ operation expert has been stung (clichéd, but irresistible).

GOOD NEWS

The person who was victimised has come courageously forward to accuse him, thereby, seeking justice for herself.

BAD NEWS

As is usual, attempts were made to cast aspersions on her and her version of events.

GOOD NEWS

The perpetrator has through his actions, emails and contradictory statements implicated himself.

BAD NEWS

If we can for a moment separate the person from the publication, we need to admit that Tehelka was doing good, some would say great, work in exposing corrupt practices, criminal activities of the establishment and highlighting rampant injustices in our system. With this ignominious episode and its aftermath spelling the doom and subsequent closure of this publication, we can no more expect any more Tehelka-style exposes.

GOOD NEWS

In his column in Kafila, journalist Rahul Roy exposes the story behind some exposes which were suppressed and tells us just how corrupt Tehelka itself had become, and how partisan and self-serving was the head of the publication to his own selfish interests.

BAD NEWS

If  a journalist – an educated, informed person can be subject to sexual harassment, imagine this to be the tip of a rather murky iceberg, exposed to the world. We shudder to think what must be the state of the female labour force in the corporate, health, education, technology and worse, the unorganised and domestic labour force.

GOOD NEWS

The publicity of this incident and awareness of their rights has prompted others to now follow suit. And better yet, it has lent credibility to the woman’s version of similar incidents, which until now, was always scoffed at or worse, discredited.

As I write this, eleven women working in K.E.M.Hospital have complained about a male co-worker’s harassment. Hopefully, others will follow suit.

BAD NEWS

Shoma Chaudhary, a journalist whose work I have long admired comes through in a less than flattering light, for her reluctance/delay in setting up the enquiry cell as was required by her, under the Vishaka guidelines.

GOOD NEWS

This will certainly (or hopefully) prod other similarly reluctant heads of institutions, to speed up the setting up enquiry cells/committees.

BAD NEWS

The forwarded email with the salacious details of the ‘episode’ ( as well as the identity of the victim) and the gobbling up of its contents points to a definite dearth of moral code of ethics in the general Indian public.

GOOD NEWS

Er…None that I can see, I am afraid!

Unless, some hacker of hackers figures out who is responsible and punishment is meted out, at least, to the source of the leak.

BAD NEWS

The treatment of the erstwhile Tehelka chief like a Buzkashi Carcass (Rahul Roy’s apt phrase, I am afraid) and the moral posturing of most men who are commenting about his behaviour (including the frenzied media interviewers) would have us believe that Mr. Tejpal was the lone wolf in India, who was preying on young women.

If we gave all their cupboards a solid shove, I wonder what rattles we would hear!

GOOD NEWS

The Omerta (Roy’s words, again) of the old boys’ network has been pried open – just a teeny-tiny bit, mind you. The Think Fest excesses, villas in Goa, payment of staff members and so on, are now in the news.

So, before this window closes again and they circle the wagons and close up once more (already happening), I wonder, what else will tumble out.

BAD NEWS

The judiciary and legislature, where these and similar complaints will ultimately end up, either a supplicant for justice or a Law needing debate, already have their version of Tehelka, one involving a Supreme Court Judge and the other a Prime Ministerial hopeful.

Speaks volumes for the hope, which is being held out for women in this situation.

GOOD NEWS

I am totally stumped on this one. Any suggestions?

I am sure, all the working women who have to fight, struggle for their due and outperform their male counterparts every single day, whilst simultaneously being watchful about the roving hands and eyes, will be earnestly watching the progress of this case.

Hope that with time, the good news outnumbers the bad, though.

I am Ujwala Shenoy Karmarkar. I love reading, meeting people, listening to music, watching plays,

Learn More

VIDEO OF THE WEEK

Comments

3 Comments


  1. Yes, hope the good news outnumbers the bad.

  2. Pingback: How society convinces victims of sexual assault to keep quiet

Share your thoughts! [Be civil. No personal attacks. Longer comment policy in our footer!]

NOVEMBER's Best New Books by Women Authors!

Stay updated with our Weekly Newsletter or Daily Summary - or both!

TRUE BEAUTY