Anupama writes a letter to her 18-years old daughter. Read what she has to say.
We talk about women empowerment but we only address one half of the equation. If we encourage our daughters to go and conquer the world, why don’t we teach our sons that it is okay to be a stay-at-home father, to cook or to express emotions?
One of the hot button topics right now in the Indian media is the safety of women – or rather how our country doesn’t really care about half its population. From rape, sexual assault, harassment (in streets, public transport, nearly every public place) to violence perpetrated on women, Indians are finally getting around to discussing taboo topics.
One refrain that caught my eye throughout these debates – both online and off – is the fact that the reaction of the majority of Indians is the same: girls should stay at home, not go out after dark, dress appropriately and so on if they want to stay safe. No one seems to bat an eyelid when laying down these precautions for women. Except that the reality is that women would be far safer if all the men simply DID NOT RAPE or HARASS any person that looks remotely female. There will be no need for men or women to stay at home and isolate themselves from society.
That got me thinking further. For at least a generation now – especially in urban India and educated middle-class families – we have raised our girls to be confident and fight for their rights. But we seem to have ignored an entire generation of boys who were not told anything about how their sisters were changing. While we gave our daughters new ideals and role models, no one bothered to tell their brothers that they ought to change too!
Let me give a few examples.
Essential life skills – driving and cooking
In many cities and towns, girls drive two-wheelers and cars. It is considered an essential life skill if you want to study and work. You can often hear dads proudly proclaiming that their daughters can drive very well indeed and they don’t need a boyfriend/husband to take them anywhere.
However, boys were never taught that cooking is an essential life skill. You don’t see parents proudly saying that their son can cook and doesn’t need a wife/girlfriend to feed him (and keep him alive!). As a result, very few men cook after they get married (never mind that they used to when they were bachelors) and the expectation is that the wife will take care of the kitchen even when both partners are working.
Identity issues and self-esteem
We tell our daughters that is it okay for them to have a career and do the jobs that were reserved solely for men. Working women are looked upon as confident and independent people.
But we don’t tell our sons that it is okay for them to be paid less than their wives or stay at home to take care of the kids while their spouses continue to work. So what is the result we have today? Many women actually have options – they can continue to work or stay at home when they get married or have children. For the men? No such luck. They are openly derided or laughed at if they don’t have a job.
We don’t tell our sons that it is okay for them to be paid less than their wives or stay at home to take care of the kids while their spouses continue to work. Men are openly derided or laughed at if they don’t have a job.
Expectations and realities of marriage
The same difference in expectations pops up when looking for a life partner as well. Many young women today expect their husbands to treat them as equal partners – whether in terms of finances, household chores, who takes care of the kids or family responsibilities.
On the other hand, I’ve seen countless examples of men who wanted to marry a working woman (in theory) but were completely unprepared for the practical reality of a marriage where both partners work. It means doing the dishes or supervising the maid when your wife has a report to complete, it means taking half the day off to take care of your sick son because your wife has an important presentation. It may even mean giving up a promotion or moving to a new city for your spouse’s career.
Because we don’t tell our sons all this, they continue to expect that their wife will automatically give up the job/promotion/transfer in favour of the family whereas they will never have to take a step back from their own careers.
This difference becomes even more stark when you consider families with only daughters or only sons. My own family was one such. My sister and I were raised by my parents to be the best people we could be and never held back because we were girls. We drove our own vehicles, carried our own luggage, managed our finances and filed taxes and did all the countless little things that you have to do when you live on your own.
It wasn’t actually until we started looking at potential life partners that I realized that boys are still raised the way they were for the last two generations. While I was looking for a man who would treat me as an equal and be my partner in life, the men I met were still concerned with whether I could cook or wear a sari!
So what are we left with at the end of the day? Indian men and women are still scrambling to reconcile their expectations with reality. Both men and women bear the burden of this lopsided upbringing. Women are upset that dinner – and the house, kids, in-laws, maid – is still their responsibility while the men don’t know what they did wrong. After all, they ‘allow’ their wives to work, what more do they want?
Both men and women bear the burden of this lopsided upbringing. Women are upset that dinner – and the house, kids, in-laws, maid – is still their responsibility while the men don’t know what they did wrong. After all, they ‘allow’ their wives to work, what more do they want?
Women know that they can be assertive at work and pursue ‘masculine’ things like investing in the stock market but men do not know that they can cry and show emotions or pursue ‘feminine’ hobbies like cooking. We coach our daughters on how to stay safe outside at night but we don’t tell our sons to step up if they see a man harassing a woman in public. Women are applauded for stepping out of the home but men are shamed for daring to stay inside.
My intention is not to minimise the sufferings that women still go through in modern India – we haven’t managed to stop the practice of dowry, selective abortion of female fetuses and the countless other ills plaguing our country. But there is no way we can solve the problem just by focusing on one half of the equation. We tell our daughters that they can be and do whatever they want in life. It’s about time we started telling our sons the exact same thing.
Image via Shutterstock.
I have my head in the clouds and feet on the ground. While I dream
Great Shilpa, for highlighting many important aspects that we need to tell our sons. Even I had felt similar thoughts running in my mind:
1. A woman is ‘blamed’ or asked about the expansion of the family (i.e. whether she is pregnant and if not whether she is planning something and couple of advises that ‘things’ should happen at the appropriate time else you would miss the bus….blahblah).
2. A woman asked to wear toe ring to benefit her uterus in some way. Whereas a man does not need to do anything for have a good sperm count and healthy sperms, which are equally important for getting a good progeny.
3. A pregnant woman is asked to go to temple, but the husband keeps going to bars. Fine the child is in her womb, but can the husband also contribute to the well-being by walking hand in hand and praying to the benefit of all. Won’t it help secrete certain brain chemicals in the wife, which would give calm and comfort to her.
4. During festivals a woman is expected to decorate the house whereas a man comes back on time from office only to eat the sweets prepared by the wife. Let us treat rangoli as an art form, which can be done by both genders rather than by a woman alone. Don’t men do paintings, sculptures and make craft items?
5. If sanskar says respect elders, then why the boys are not taught to respect his in-laws. Leave alone not getting up and touching their feet, but even the basic respect as another human deserves, is not given and they are treated more like door mats in many families. What are they teaching their children??!!
Fine the list is long…but the gist being – Let us bring up same value system in both boys and girls, because law does not differentiate crimes and offences done based on gender. Law does not say…”oh, you are a man, hence you are entitled to be more irritated and angry and hence you can beat up a fellow man, but a woman should endure somethings with patience….”. Offence is an offence….trait is a trait…attitude is attitude…..right?!
Thanks for sharing your thoughts! Yes I certainly agree that crimes do not vary depending on gender. It’s also interesting how often things like pregnancy, sex, culture, religious duties etc gets foisted on the shoulders of women and yet, they’re supposed to be the weaker gender?!
An especially annoying issue is this: When a woman gives birth to a girl (in this society which values a penis so much), it’s somehow supposed to be her fault even though the appropriate chromosome has to be contributed by the father! I mean WTF?
Pingback: ‘Beauty’- The Bane Of Every Woman’s Life! – Aura with Writing
A good topic and good points raised by you. But I do not agree with few topics that you have discussed. First of all if we are encouraging our daughters to go out and conquer the world, we have the same feeling with our son to go out and conquer the world, why we should teach him that it is okay to be a stay-at-home father? If we are following this criteria don’t you think that we are going to the concept of making the same old problem that was the main reason of your article, “women empowerment”, may be after some time it will be converted into “men empowerment”, after some decades someone will be writing a article visa versa with the same scenario. It is just a thought.
As far as you have written that in many cities and towns, girls drive two wheelers and cars and boys were never taught that cooking is an essential life skill. But there are many girls also who do not know a single letter from cooking and there are boys also who are master in cooking. I am not discussing the example of some popular man chefs, but I am talking about normal boys who know cooking and they cooks in their home without any issue.
As far as I think here the issue is not of girl and boy but the issue is of rich and poor. In a rich home there can be girls who do not know cooking and in a poor home there can be boy who know each and every thing that you are saying are business of a girl and boys are not involved in it.
Though I agree with the topic that you have discussed but I think the examples you have given are not quite appropriate.
I have many examples where man is earning less or even dependent on women. But this is not the topic of discussion here, in fact in my opinion now days it is not the gender but it is the society who makes the real difference.
Pingback: When Women Patrons Of The Written Word Met At The ALL Lit Fest Bangalore 2017
Pingback: Empowering women globally – organisations worth knowing about – Career Handbook
This Independence Day Let’s Take A Pledge To Liberate The Indian Men!
Why Do Boys (& Men) Dare To Say “Don’t Act Too Smart, You’re A Girl, Stay Within Your Limits”?
What, Really, Are We Teaching Our Daughters (And Sons) About Gender Equality?
Who Made These Patriarchal Rules Against Women’s Choices, And Why Should I Follow Them?
Get our weekly mailer and never miss out on the best reads by and about women!