Check out 16 Return-To-Work Programs In India For Ambitious Women Like You!
A friend's unusual question got her thinking: Do family members have the right to keep things private? Or is it secrecy?
A friend’s unusual question got her thinking: Do family members have the right to keep things private? Or is it secrecy?
One day while talking to a friend of mine, she told that she had been going through a lot of stress with her personal life.
She began lamenting that in over three years of married life, she had never seen her husband talking over the mobile. She clarified that she did not mean that he hardly spoke to anyone over the phone; rather, she meant that he spoke over the phone for hours but not at home, not even with his parents or siblings. She also stated that in all these years, she hardly knew his mobile unlock pin or pattern.
At first, I told her that she might be unnecessarily over thinking on the issue and feeling unnecessary stress. She then explained to me that initially, she too felt the same, “What’s there if he doesn’t talk at home!”
But then, she added that even when the two of them went out somewhere, he would go a little farther away from her to attend any calls, be it professional or from his parents or siblings or friends. She ended by saying that it all went to such an extent that people in the neighbourhood started advising her to be careful in case he might be having an affair.
As a friend and well wisher, I asked her to tell me clearly if she was reacting based on others’ opinions or if she truly had any doubts about him. She clarified that she did not doubt him but at the same time, she was not feeling comfortable with him not talking in front of her. It made her feel insecure and as though she were not a part of the family. She said that she found herself lonely everyday, just like a person who was there to get the household work done.
In order not to complicate issues even more, however, I tried to convince her not to get into others’ opinions and respect each others’ privacy; I suggested that she not see it through a magnifying lens and not stress herself unnecessarily. She seemed to have convinced herself but in the end, her question made me think over it again, though I ended the conversation positively.
Is it privacy or secrecy?
Empathy, we call it. To be able to be in another’s shoes and understand their situation. I tried to answer her question for myself but couldn’t convince myself as confidently as I had tried to convince her. I fell into a basic doubt as to what is privacy and what is secrecy.
What is called personal space for an individual, be it a man or woman, after marriage? If a couple is married and meant to live a life together for the rest of their lives, forming a family, how is personal space defined for each other?
If one can’t even talk to one’s parents or siblings in front of the other, is it privacy or secrecy? As we were always taught, secrecy is anything that we hide from another. And privacy is something which we do for ourselves, not in front of everyone.
But in this case, when I truly tried to answer her questions myself, I found myself in a fix, unable to differentiate or convince myself on an issue where I had easily tried my best to convince another person. If it is privacy, then isn’t she a family member, and will there be anything personal or private among family members? If not, is it secrecy that he doesn’t want her to know whom he is talking to?
This has once again taught me that it’s not always as easy as it seems to be, unless we truly try to empathise with the other person.
Image credits: Studio Roman via Canva Pro
read more...
Women's Web is an open platform that publishes a diversity of views, individual posts do not necessarily represent the platform's views and opinions at all times.
Stay updated with our Weekly Newsletter or Daily Summary - or both!
People say that women are the greatest enemies of women. I vehemently disagree. It is the patriarchal mindset that makes women believe in the wrong ideology.
The entire world celebrates International Women’s Day on March 8, 2024. It should be a joyful day, but unfortunately, not all women are entitled to this privilege, as violence against women is at its peak. The experience of oppression pushes many women to choose freedom. As far as patriotism is concerned, feminism is not a cup of tea in this society.
What happens when a woman decides to stand up for herself? Does this world easily accept the decisions of women in this society? What inspires them to be free of the clutches of the oppression that women have faced for ages? Most of the time, women do not get the chance to decide for themselves. Their lives are always at the mercy of someone, which can be their parents, siblings, husband, or children.
In some cases, women do not feel the need to make any decisions. They are taught to obey the patriarchal system, which makes them believe that they are right. In my family, I was never taught to make decisions on my own. It was always my parents who bought dresses and all that I needed.
14 years after her last feature film Dhobi Ghat, storyteller extraordinaire comes up with her new film, Laapataa Ladies, a must watch.
*Some spoilers alert*
Every religion around the world dictates terms to women. The onus is always on women to be ‘modest’ and cover their faces and bodies so men can’t be “tempted”, rather than on men to keep their eyes where they belong and behave like civilized beings. So much so that even rape has been excused on the grounds of women eating chowmein or ‘men will be men’. I think the best Hindi movie retort to this unwanted advice on ‘akeli ladki khuli tijori ki tarah hoti hai’ (an alone woman is like an open jewellery box) came from Geet in Jab We Met – Kya aap gyan dene ke paise lete hain kyonki chillar nahin hain mere paas.
The premise of Laapataa Ladies is beautifully simple – two brides clad in the ghunghat that covers their identity get mixed up on a train. Within this Russian Doll, you get a comedy of errors, a story of getting lost, a commentary on patriarchy’s attitude towards women, a mystery, and a tale of finding oneself, all in one. Done with a mostly light touch that has you laughing and nodding along.
Please enter your email address