Come along and join us on our new Telegram channel! Telegram is an alternative instant messaging and voice app – pretty similar to WhatsApp ( We will no longer be available on WhatsApp)
The much awaited Triple Talaq bill has generated a lot of buzz, but the Muslim community, including Muslim women, is not very happy with the way the bill is framed.
It has been agreed on a large scale by the Muslim community that Instant Triple Talaq has to go and activists from the community have been fighting against the Instant Triple Talaq (TT).While the SC decision to ban Instant TT was widely welcomed by the community, many are apprehensive about the government ‘s step to criminalise this act.
The urgency in turning a civil dispute into a criminal offence has raised many questions. Under the new law the offence is non-bailable and cognizable, which means it does not need a complaint by the wife or anyone for the cops to arrest or investigate a Muslim man. So by default, any Muslim man who wants a divorce can be held guilty of the offence, and be arrested and jailed for three years. As the divorce is declared invalid by the SC, the wife continues to be bound in an unhappy marriage for that period and issues like maintanence and child custody will remain unresolved.
The entire burden of the family falls on the wife and if the woman is not economically independent, who will support the family financially is a big question. With the husband in jail, any help from his family is least expected and if it a was a bad and abusive marriage, the wife will now be forced to stay in the marriage.
The major concerns with the law are:
– The offence is non-bailable and cognizable wherein the man is jailed for three years.
– The issue of maintainance and financial responsibility for the family remains unresolved
– The wife is forced to be in an unhappy marriage and faces an uncertain future
– Most importantly, the community fears that the law will be used to target and prosecute Muslim men
The incidents of lynchings of Muslims in the name of beef laws and love jihad has created a fear in the minds of many Muslims. Not only is the government silent with no condemnation of the incidents, cases have been registered against the victims, adding to the growing fear. Under the present situation, the Triple Talaq bill pushed through with urgency is not getting a very positive response from the community.
Activists and women who were strongly speaking against Instant TT themselves are raising many questions about the bill. Some of the questions raised are, as instant triple talaq stands void as already declared by the SC, then why are they imposing a criminal penalty on someone for it? Muslim women feel the Triple Talaq bill does not do much for their protection in the long run. On the contrary, due to the fear of prosecution, many Muslim men instead of divorcing their wives may now simply abandon them and opt for a second marriage, indirectly promoting polygamy. The abandoned wife is held captive in a failed marriage and any chances of starting her life afresh are closed forever.
She further has to face the social consequences of the issue; she will end up being an abandoned wife with an uncertain future or she will be held guilty for jailing the man who still continues to be her husband.
The argument that merely banning Instant Triple Talaq was not sufficient and the criminalisation will act as a deterrent may initially seem fair but on detailed analysis of the Talaq scenario one realises that how it will create more problems for Muslim women.
The general response of the community is that Instant TT needs to go but the bill in it’s present form doesn’t provide a reasonable solution to the problem and the government needs to draft a better bill covering all the issues and concerns of the community.
Top image via Pixabay
Women's Web is an open platform that publishes a diversity of views. Individual posts do not necessarily represent the platform's views and opinions at all times. If you have a complementary or differing point of view, sign up and start sharing your views too!
Dentist ,writer ,blogger and strongly opinionated .
Nice article and well articulated. My own view is that there may not actually be a need for a separate legislation simply because instant Talaq has no recognition in Islam and therefore, a man who says Talaq thrice at one go, is only administering Talaq ‘once’ and therefore, is still married to his wife. If after that he refuses to provide for his wife and children, he is committing an offence both legally and in the eyes of religion as well. There would certainly be existing legislation which can be strengthened to tackle this.
To all the Muslims who are protesting, they failed to follow Islamic practices on marriage and divorce so beautifully laid out in Surah An-Nisa in the Holy Quran as well as the Hadith. They did not set their own house in order and brought things to a situation, where Government had to intervene.
Pingback: Why Muslim women are not happy with the Triple Talaq Bill – Kouserf
Triple Talaq Bill Approved In A Historic Session: Empowering But Could Also Be Problematic
There’s More To Muslim Divorce Than Triple Talaq!
Triple Talaq Verdict: SC Set The Bar High, But We Still Need More
4 Jaw-Dropping Judgements Of 2018 That Will Pave The Way For Equality
Get our weekly mailer and never miss out on the best reads by and about women!