December's writing theme is active now! Get Inspired by Shashi Deshpande and send us your entry!
daughterschoolwork

Schools Versus Working Mothers In India

POSTED: September 10, 2010

Working mothers are redefining the role of women in India; yet schools refuse admission to the children of working mothers! 

Kavita Rawat*, 35, Programme Head with a television channel has a busy day packed with meetings. Which is why she finds it difficult to take time out on a working day to attend school meetings (deemed compulsory by the school); not to mention, events at school for which parents need to contribute various dishes cooked in the morning before the child leaves for class. Welcome to the world of working mothers in India!

“I have tried explaining to the class teacher and coordinator that they need to schedule Parent Teacher Meets on weekends to allow working parents to attend, but to no avail,” she says. Her child’s school does not have a PTA to which she can take her issues. If you are a working woman with a school going child, you will definitely identify with Kavita’s problems.

Working mother in India? No admission for your child!

While many women today juggle a career, home and childcare (and childcare still is considered primarily the mother’s responsibility), some schools still frame policies assuming a mother who is a full-time homemaker. Parents claim that a few schools do not even consider children of working mothers for admission. Schools, for obvious reasons, refuse to discuss the subject, let alone admitting to the practice.

Many working mothers in India have experienced bias at the school admission interview. Seema Kohli*, 32, Media Planner with an advertising agency was asked by a school principal whether the money she earned justified leaving her child in the care of maids during her formative years. Naturally, her child wasn’t admitted in that school. Having learnt her lesson, she put herself down as a homemaker for the next round of school admissions and made it through.

Seema Kohli*, 32, Media Planner with an advertising agency was asked by a school principal whether the money she earned justified leaving her child in the care of maids during her formative years.

Says Renu Menon*, 32, Project Manager with a telecommunications firm in Chennai who has recently relocated to the US, “While I was searching for a school for my daughter, I heard that some schools in Chennai would not consider you if you put yourself down as a working mom. And these are considered some of the leading schools.” Luckily for Renu, moving to the US meant that her daughter was admitted in a school which has no issue with working mothers, and also offers extended childcare on school premises where her daughter can stay until either parent picks her up.

Says Terence Phillips, Educationist (retired), “I have not carried out a research into whether schools prefer children of ‘Stay at Home’ mothers as against ‘Working’ mothers, nor am I aware of such a study having been carried out in India. However, as an educationist I believe that children must not be discriminated against for any reason whatsoever. If a school prefers to admit children from a particular background only, it would amount to discrimination.”

Schools blind to changing role of women in India?

Smriti Lamech, Journalist with a women’s magazine, says, “While I can never be 100% sure about the admission process, I was not a working mother when my son began play school and filled up his form saying ‘Stay-at-home-mom’. I joined work a couple of months later. But right through PTA meetings the principal often called out to the working mothers by name and made pointed references to the fact that they worked and insisted that they probably neglected their children. There were often events in the middle of the morning that the parent was supposed to attend and she even said she thought children should be picked up from school only by their mothers.”

…right through PTA meetings the principal often called out to the working mothers by name and made pointed references to the fact that they worked and insisted that they probably neglected their children.

Event schedules are often so thoughtlessly planned as to take no account of the constraints of dual-working families. Mothers find it tough to squeeze time out for parent-teacher conferences, music and dance performances, athletic events, award ceremonies, field trips and even volunteering for tuck day and such. Organizing fancy dress costumes which require hunting down fabric and getting it stitched, a time intensive process is something other schools insist on, with a ban on ready to hire costumes which a working mother would consider time-saving.

Fear that children of working mothers are ‘neglected’

According to June Dutt, Educationist Consultant with Sri Sri Academy (Curriculum Advisor and Teacher’s Training), “From what I have seen 20 years ago, to policies today, I think schools are changing their approach towards working moms, whether still married or single. Earlier, schools were a bit wary of admitting children of single working moms because of issues like financial instability if the mother was not earning adequately or the fear that the father might come to the schools and create unpleasant scenes.” Today, she feels, schools do not look askance at admitting children of working moms, but are proactive to work with the parents to ensure the child is cared for.

Her primary issue, as she sees it, is that parents should endeavour to keep the children in the care of a responsible adult from the family, like a grandparent, with a maid to help. “I’ve been a working mother all my life,” she says candidly, “but I did have the advantage of being able to leave my children behind with their grandparents. Plus I was a teacher, so my hours were easier. Working women today have the disadvantage of having to live in nuclear families, and there is a lack of professionally managed day care systems in India where children can go to after schools. So, many children are either alone at home or under the supervision of a maid.” 

Indeed, among the questions asked of the parents during the interview which goes under the moniker ‘interaction’ these days is “Who looks after the child if the mother is working?” June corroborates this. “With working mothers, my experience has been that schools do tend to ask who the primary caretaker of the child is, in the parents’ absence.” 

Simultaneously, there are principals who understand that given women’s career aspirations and the cost of living these days, double income families are inevitable. Says the Principal of a long established Mumbai suburban school, “I find that children with working mothers become independent and self-sufficient earlier than other kids in their peer group. We do insist though that working moms make an effort to participate in school activities that their child is part of, but we try to ensure that the timings are convenient.” 

She adds, with a little laugh, “After all, I have also been a working mother all my career.”

* Names changed on request to protect identities.

Women's Web

Women's Web

Women's Web is a vibrant community for Indian women, an authentic space for us to be ourselves and talk about all things that matter to us. Follow us via the Facebook or Twitter. Become a registered user, and you'll be eligible for our free ebooks plus never miss our newsletter or event notifications.

Author's Blog: http://www.womensweb.in/

Facebook Comments

4 Comments


  1. Very thoughtful article. Thanks women web for raising these critical but often neglected issues.
    I would like to add a point that a child is not only a mother’s responsibility. This is whole societies responsibility to look after and nurture a child. In earlier times, in joint families all the mothers together looked after each other’s children, because some mothers had to involve in cooking, washing and do other domestic chores for the family. So now why is it portrayed that mothers who are working means they are selfish towards their children. Why cannot it can be seen like that they are trying to make a path for the next generation girls to carry on with their family and career together? I am a single working mom outside India and I must admit the school and society (specially other moms who are at home by choice) are so co-operating that I never feel any guilty of working. There is never any comparison or competition. I don’t know when India will understand this logic.

  2. This is an interesting article; I’m amazed schools are so sexist. I wish the article had stressed more that taking care of kids is the responsibility of both parents and that both parents should be involved in school activities. Thus, it is a problem that pertains to dual income households and maybe we should stop framing it as a woman’s issue only.
    I’m assuming many of these school principals are women. So aren’t they working mums themselves? Weird that they can’t see the irony.
    I wish working parents could get together and organise some kind of protest or legal action against this nonsense.

  3. Guest Blogger

    @The Bride – Childcare should be both parents’ responsibility, and we have a responsibility to frame it that way, so thank you for pointing that out. In this case, schools’ framework is based on a mother who is at home full-time and also,, their expectations are primarily from moms (which itself is a problem) – hence the emphasis.

  4. Wow!! I am amazed at such behavior from schools. The principals who so rudely insist that working mothers are not taking proper care of their kids are themselves working mothers – how do they forget that? Growing up, I didn’t see or hear about this attitude. Is this a new trend? Or just limited to certain cities/areas? Boy, am I glad that we moved to the US!!

Share your thoughts! [Be civil. No personal attacks. Longer comment policy in our footer!]

Follow Women's Web

Stay updated with our Weekly Newsletter or Daily Summary - or both!